Showing posts with label journal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label journal. Show all posts

Thursday, November 23, 2017

Journal: Generic Everyman Protagonist

Journal: Generic Everyman Protagonists
by
Paul Adams
So, today I want to talk about the “Generic Everyman Protagonist” common in fiction, or for sake of brevity, the G.E.P. The most notable representatives pf this of course being Harry Potter, Percy Jackson, Frodo Baggins, and Luke Skywalker in movies and books, and most of the protagonists of video games. Now these characters can come in all shapes and sizes, though they are often the most common ethnicity in the country of the work's origin, and are often male though there are more than a few females in this role ( a surprisingly high amount in manga and anime, see: Lucy in Fairy Tale). Hence the reason for the four examples listed above all being white males as they are the best known to an American audience. I will be getting into this more later.
Now, the “Generic Everyman Protagonist” exists primarily in the science fiction or fantasy genre but can crop up in other genres. Their purpose in most cases is to give the audience a “lowest common denominator” of sorts to relate to, a center of stability and familiarity to see this strange new world through. In some ways, the basic-ness of their character is their greatest strength. If you are trying to show your audience this vast world or concept that you’ve created, you don’t want them to be constantly distracted because their proxy in the world has way too much going on.
Before I get started, there are a couple of troublesome factors involved. Like I pointed out earlier, many of these types of characters are often white straight males (in Western media, at least). Whether this is whitewashing or social whatever is not something I want to tackle here, but it does feed into the concept brought up in the preceding paragraph, about them having too much going on. Often, but not always, if your protagonist is female, she tends to carry into the story a certain degree of feminist angle. Instead of being first and foremost an observer of the world around her, most of the audience will want her to be a role model, an action hero, the center of the plot's attention at all times, and the writer will factor that in, and as a result, the world that they're supposed to be showing us will not be as developed. The same can be said for a dark-skinned protagonist, homosexual protagonist, or otherwise. Whether you support the causes or not, this can the quickest way to distract from the world you’re trying to present, or such characters and issues can be easily mishandled and authors will avoid them just so they don’t cause more problems. That said, that trend seems to be changing as “G.E.P.s” such as Katniss Everdeen of The Hunger Games and Rey and Finn of the newest Star Wars film did a solid job of filling their role without getting bogged down in these ways.
Another point of contention arises when you use this kind of character to explore other real life cultures, to present a culture your intended audience may not be familiar with by using a G.E.P. they can relate to. Such examples are The Last Samurai and Dances with Wolves. These kinds of stories will often be criticized for “racial appropriation,” especially if the G.E.P., rather than simply experiencing this culture they’re unfamiliar with and connecting to it, rises through the ranks of the culture and becomes their “best” member, their chief or chosen one or hero. This is understandable in some respects, as the hierarchy or fighting styles of the culture are often an important part of said culture, and letting the G.E.P. rise through the ranks lets them experience the culture on all levels, and narratively, it can give structure or purpose to your plot. I think, in the end, it just requires balance. And even if you take them to the upper echelons of the culture, try to avoid placing them at the very top if you can.
Now that the touchy subjects are out of the way, let’s focus on what makes Harry, Frodo, Percy, and Luke work but not others. I think it is a common misconception that because your protagonist is a G.E.P., that means that you don’t have to try with their characters. That you can just place the character in position, have them say the right things and ask the right questions, and that’s it. But I think it’s the opposite. I think the G.E.P. may be the most important character to get right. If you are supposed to experience the world through their eyes, then you are going to need them to be as human as they possibly can be. They need to feel the world around them. They need to care about the world around them. If the reader is to truly live within the world the author is presenting them, they need to feel it the way the G.E.P. character feels it. If the protagonist is simply walking through this “interesting world” of theirs and just kind of staring at it all without feeling any of it, the reader is not going to feel any of it. Although the G.E.P. may have the least going on, plot and characterwise, they need to be the most vibrantly human character in your story. Because in the end, the plot and world is their story, so they have to fill it with every ounce of emotion and feeling that they can.
Harry, Frodo, and Percy were all book characters first, so we were in their heads more than in other mediums. The world of Hogwarts only came to life for readers because it came to life for Harry. After living his life in a broom cupboard, the astonishment he felt exploring every last inch of his new magical world exceeded what would have been felt by almost anyone else, and that wonder came across in every last detail he took in. Frodo had lived his entire life in the sheltered community of the Shire, so every step he took beyond it was filled with terror and uncertainty about this vast world far different from his idyllic home. Percy had a wit and charm to his narration that colored the world that he explored, easing the tension that came with his cliché story arc and ensured that the old Greek myths he stumbled across were firmly translated into something a modern audience would understand.
Luke Skywalker on the other hand is a movie character first and foremost, and so the audience is not inside his head as much as they were inside Harry’s or Frodo’s or Percy’s. But the same principles still apply. Luke was a dreamer, a man who had lived his whole life on a barren farm, and could only imagine what was beyond the stars. When he stepped beyond his world, he was constantly learning and interacting with his new world. Though sometimes he was whiny and stubborn about learning it, he still had a sense of wonder and curiosity that allowed him to see as much of it as he could.
Now, I want to talk about the history of the G.E.P. in video games because theirs is an interesting history. For up to about the turn of the last century in video games, the sole purpose of the game was the gameplay mechanics themselves, and any plot was kept as basic as possible. This is the main reason for the longevity of the character Mario, as his creator Shigeru Miyamoto has continually gone out of his way to keep Mario as basic as possible, focusing on gameplay first, and simply adjusting him to fit whatever new game mechanics they came up with. Some games ended up as duds, but none ever truly hindered Mario’s success overall. Other games trying to compete with Mario, such as Sonic or Bubsy, were created as marketable characters first, and then had games built around them, and their success was often hindered by that fact.
Other games, especially the Role-Playing Game genre and occasionally the Action Adventure genre, including such franchises as Pokemon, The Legend of Zelda, and Final Fantasy, will intentionally go out of their way to make the player character as generic and unremarkable as possible, letting you name the character yourself and never having the character talk, so that you, the player, can then fill the character with your own personality and interests, so that you can “role-play” as them, if you will. In some ways, this is the best use of the G.E.P. for the video game genre, as the purpose of a G.E.P. in the first place is to give the audience someone to explore the world through, and in an interactive medium such as video games, you are the one exploring the world, so adding unnecessary personality will just get in the way more than it will help.
Around the turn of the last century, late 1990s to early 2000s, video games started to become far more cinematic as technology improved and creators were able to do more with what they had, and characters became more human and fleshed out than simple iconic cartoon animals. As more and more intricate stories and depth were added, video games became more akin to movies, but with an added element of your own involvement. This led to an interesting growth in the G.E.P. as creators learned new ways of giving the main character personality while allowing the player to still explore the world in their own way and make their own choices. Some games, such as Mass Effect and Undertale, featured massively branching storylines that made every choice you make matter, and no single playthrough of the games was ever the same twice, and the personality of the player character was slightly altered in each storyline to match the choices the player made, ranging from complete monster to noble hero and every shade in between. Interactive storytelling in video games has changed the G.E.P. into a fusion of generic and complex by allowing the player to determine just what kind of person their character is.

So, this has been a wide look at the “Generic Everyman Protagonist” and the problems and qualities contained therein, and the way they have impacted and been impacted by the mediums they appear in. They are something to remember for my writing, especially as Gavin bears many similarities to these types of protagonists. I don’t know if books or movies will ever be able to accomplish the same kind of level games have taken G.E.P.s to, but I suppose that’s why we have these different types of mediums. But I think we can learn from all forms of storytelling in order to make our own better.

Thanks for reading. Comment below and follow me for more.

Thursday, November 16, 2017

Journal: Strawmen

THE POINT OF A STRAWMAN
by
Paul Adams
            So, I’m sure you’re aware of the trope known as the Strawman, a flat two-dimensional character designed only to push or discredit a certain political viewpoint. Whether they be an arrogant money-grubbing billionaire to represent Conservatives or a wild and selfish teenager who cares only about themselves to represent Liberals, a womanizing, wife-beating pig to push Feminism or a shrill screaming harpy to discredit Feminism, a foolish Bible-thumping prude or a drunk faithless washout to push religious perspectives, the Strawman is probably one of the most aggravating tropes in fiction.
            However, on a recent viewing of The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King, I became interested in the character of Denethor, played by John Noble. Denethor in many ways is very much a Strawman, representing a ruler whose concern is centered entirely on himself and his throne while having little to no concern for his subjects. When Gandalf and Pippin arrive in his court, urging him to call for help against his enemies, he refuses simply on the grounds of keeping his throne. He sends his son Faramir and their entire army to their deaths, enjoying a personal feast as they do so. And when Faramir is brought back wounded, he goes out of his way to portray himself as a martyr, refusing treatment for his son, and attempting to have them both burned on a pyre.
            Through all of this, I noticed that Denethor, unlike many Strawman similar to him, never became egregious. You never felt like you were being bashed over the head with some director’s personal political agenda. I stopped to consider why that was, and in doing so, I asked myself what is a Strawman? My answer was that a Strawman represents the extreme of any political viewpoint, a representation of what happens when that political viewpoint is taken too far or set out of balance.
            So, where does this fit into the process of storytelling. Naturally, the Strawman is a trope that should be used to show the dangers of going too far with the particular viewpoint they represent. A Strawman works best when the focus is kept on that. Where a number of Strawmen fail, I’ve noticed, is when they are presented as the only example of that political viewpoint. In reality, yes, there are a number of individuals who fulfill the “Strawman” persona and feed the stereotype, but there are normally far more with a much more balanced version of that viewpoint or have some very solid human reasons for acting the way they do. When a work of fiction portrays a strawman as the only version of that viewpoint, that’s when it becomes egregious and aggravating. If a strawman is to function, they must be shown as a more-or-less special case instead of the norm.
            The second way in which a strawman fails is that the director fails to demonstrate to the audience why this way of thinking can be dangerous, and instead simply uses them as a personal punching bag. In Lord of the Rings, Denethor’s selfishness has a massive impact on the plot, resulting in the deaths of hundreds of soldiers, the emotional devastation of his son, and nearly the loss of his kingdom itself. When his karma eventually catches up to him, the audience feels as if he has earned every bit of it, and the results of such a selfish ruler are clear to the viewers.
            Far too often, we do not see the impact of these Strawmen. They simply walk into the plot, say and do the things connected to the extremes of the viewpoint represented, provide a nuisance every once in a while, and then get punished. It is very much the director or writers taking out their own political feelings against an opponent who can’t fight back.
            So, I guess that’s my conclusion. Where a Strawman fits into the world of fiction and storytelling is not as a representation of the whole or simply as a punching bag for the writer. That Strawman should stand as a special case, representing the worst of that particular leaning, and the results of their actions should be felt by the audience. In essence, a Strawman should be a teaching tool, a warning against going to political extremes. If used correctly, they can be a powerful tool in the hands of a skilled writer. If used poorly, well, the writer tends to make themselves look as foolish and closed-minded as the caricature they are trying to portray.

Thanks for reading. Comment below and follow me for more.

Thursday, October 26, 2017

Journal: The Confrontation

Journal: The Confrontation
by Paul Adams
Today, I would like to talk about the Confrontation. In case you don’t know,  the “three-act structure” consists of three parts: the setup, the confrontation, and the resolution. The setup and resolution should be generally small, taking up only a fourth or so of the total length of the story, coming at the beginning and end respectively. For a long time I considered them the most important parts of the story. If you can put together a good setup and a fulfilling climax, your story was good. The confrontation was just the in-between.
Now, while the setup and resolution are important, I’ve recently come to the conclusion that the confrontation is arguably the most important piece of your work. The confrontation itself takes up the bulk of the story, at least half of the work in the center and, like a sandwich, should contain the meat of the story’s content. The saying I’ve been using lately is that it should “show the viewer what THEY came to see.”
What do I mean by this? Well, if someone were to go to a sporting event, they wouldn’t be there to see two hours of detailed introductions on each player, manager, and ref involved, followed by about five minutes of gameplay, would they? (Of course, every sporting event I’ve ever been to seems to do this. But then, I’m not a sports guy, so what do I know?) Too often, a writer, filmmaker, musician, or otherwise forgets this. They get too wrapped up in telling THEIR story, that they forget that their audience couldn’t really care less about THEIR story. The trick, I’ve found, is to give the audience what THEY came for, and then weave YOUR story into it.
I suppose a good demonstration of this in the cinematic world is the difference between last year’s Batman v. Superman: Dawn of Justice and Pixar’s Finding Nemo. When it comes to Batman v. Superman, it should be obvious what the audience came for. Batman (wait for it) versus Superman. So then, according to the three-act structure, the first fourth of the movie should then have showed us A) who is Batman, B) who is Superman, and C) why they want to fight each other. Simple, right? Then the next hour to two hours of the movie should then have been Batman (can you guess?) fighting Superman. Some parts straight up action, some parts mental games, some parts strategy and preparation, but nevertheless a whole lot of Batman versus Superman, followed up by a satisfying conclusion that puts an end to their fighting. However, what we got was two hours of endless talking and setup, not only for Batman versus Superman but for a larger movie universe as a whole, followed by eight minutes total of actual Batman versus Superman.
Now compare that to Finding Nemo, Pixar’s endearing story about a fish father finding his fish son and crossing a whole ocean to do so. In the first fifteen minutes or so, we get a clear and concise set up of A) who Marlin is, B) who Nemo is, C) How Nemo gets captured. During the next hour or so, the audience is then treated to an adventure across a vast ocean featuring encounters with sharks, turtles, jellyfish, ocean mines, anglerfish, whales, swarms of fish, and of course Dory. Couple that off with segments of Nemo experiencing life in a fish tank, encountering his fellow fish, filters, tank features like volcanoes, kids tapping on the glass, and kids shaking the fish bag too much. All in all, more than enough to satisfy and surpass the viewers’ expectations. Then finally we get our conclusion that wraps up nicely the emotional baggage set up in the beginning.

This is something to remember throughout any genre or medium. Harry Potter, while containing several great moments of storytelling, devotes most of its time to immersing its reader in this world of magic and especially the various aspects of Hogwarts. When making a horror film, the Setup period should be spent setting up the monster and the cannon fodder, while then spending the bulk of the film building suspense and squeezing every ounce of terror from the audience. In an action movie, most of the film should be, of course, filled with non-stop action. In essence, remember what the story should be, what the audience came for, and give it to them. Whatever world you have promised them, show it to them. Nothing turns off a reader or viewer more than wanting to swim out and breathe in the full world the story has laid out for them, but constantly being driven along a narrow course through the most boring part of it just because the writer's too wrapped up in THEIR story. So, let them explore it. Immerse them in it. Give them all they hoped for and more. If you don’t, it won’t matter how good you think YOUR story is. It will never be heard.

Thanks for reading. Comment below and follow me for more.

Thursday, October 12, 2017

Journal: Franchise Building

Journal: Franchise Building
by Paul Adams
            So, here’s a thought I had on trying to start on franchises. I was recently watching a video on the recent video-game-based movie Warcraft, a film that was received with less-than-enthusiastic reception as a messy and confusing film, that was however beautiful and full of immense detail perfectly recreating the world of World of Warcraft. Several comments I read tried to defend the film, as a “worldbuilding film”: a movie that did the work of creating the world of the story so that other movies later down the road could then move in and tell an actually good story.
            As I pondered this, I considered several other works in the same vein that worked or didn’t work. The original Star Wars and Fellowship of the Ring are two of the most notable examples, films that set up a world, but still remained solid films that could be enjoyed alone. Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone did the job as well, as a book, and for the most part, as a movie. Iron Man did this for the entire thirteen films and counting of the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Films such as Dragonball Evolution, The Last Airbender, Eragon, and most recently, DC’s attempt to catch up to Marvel with Batman v. Superman, did not.
            The theory I formulated I will call the “Burger Theory.” Imagine you go to a Burger Joint and order a burger. When your food arrives, you are surprised to find only the bottom bun on your plate. You complain to your server, but he assures you that the bun is simply there to set up your burger and that if you wait two to three more years, you will get a patty. Two years after that, you’ll get your entire burger. They tell you that they hope you’ll be willing to wait that long, promising you that the burger you get in the end will be more than worth it.
            A few days later, you go to a different Burger Joint and ask for a burger. Soon enough, you are served an entire burger, and the server tells you that if you enjoyed the first, you are welcome to order a second. You eat, and it’s . . . good? Bad? Either way, you got a whole burger.
            The problem with the “It’s a worldbuilding film” defense, is that that shouldn’t be good enough. A viewer, reader, or otherwise should never be forced to settle for just a bun, hoping a great burger will come years down the road. If you did that in an actual Burger Joint, you’d never get a repeat customer. Why then, as a writer, creator, or artist, would you expect anyone to do any different when it comes to a work of fiction.
            The Marvel Cinematic Universe has grown from a simple standalone film about the origins of Iron Man to a massive interconnected universe featuring thirteen plus films, each raking in millions upon millions of dollars with every single entry, two television series, and three critically acclaimed Netflix series. Much of this wouldn’t even be possible without that first Iron Man film. One of the most important pieces to the success of Iron Man was that it remembered to tell its audience a good story. It had a charismatic and engaging lead, a clever script, and a level of depth that left the audience feeling more than satisfied. The only clue the audience had that it was supposed to lead into a wider universe didn’t even come until the now-famous postcredits scene, in which Samuel L. Jackson’s Nick Fury appears to Tony Stark to talk to him about the “Avenger Initiative.” In a figurative sense, the servers waited until the patrons had finished up their delicious burger before approaching and offering them a little bit more.
            On the other side of that coin was DC’s Batman v. Superman. The history of DC films is a rocky one. For many years, the only movies based on DC characters were Batman or Superman films, half of which were often poorly received. Their greatest claim to fame was Christopher Nolan’s Dark Knight trilogy. Nearly any attempt they had made to branch out to other properties were often met with catastrophic failure, some few examples being Supergirl, Catwoman, and Green Lantern. During all of this, Marvel slowly built up their cinematic behemoth, dwarfing DC and leaving them far behind in the dust.
            Their latest Superman film Man of Steel was met with mixed reviews, but DC was done with being left behind by Marvel. In a risky and desperate move, they pumped millions of dollars into jumpstarting a combined universe off of Man of Steel’s groundwork, their first entry being what they thought would be a shoe-in with Batman v. Superman: Dawn of Justice. What we got instead was a tedious and messy movie, skipping several of the much needed steps Marvel had taken by building up their universe slowly over time, instead opting to throw as much at the screen as they could, shouting to the audience, “Hey, look, it’s Wonder Woman! Hey, look, we’ve got the Flash! Aquaman! Let’s throw in Doomsday and kill off Superman in the second outing, instead of way down the line as it should be! That’ll get us back up to Marvel’s level.”
            In a sense, DC gave us a plate chock-full of fries and chocolate sundaes and sodas and salads around a single bun, when all we’d wanted was a simple burger.

            In the end, works like Iron Man, Star Wars, Fellowship, and Harry Potter did not try to force their great expanded universes on anyone. They told an interesting story and left their audiences feeling satisfied and excited. They got their sequels because the viewers wanted more. They delivered their promised burger, and the audience came back for seconds. Movies like Batman v. Superman and Warcraft tried to feed their viewers a piece of a story, making grand shows about having much more to come without actually delivering in the first outing. When this comes to my writing, it reflects how I used to go about writing the story versus what I’m trying to do now. Originally, my first book was full of stuff that led into later books without necessarily going anywhere and getting the audience lost and confused. In my newest attempt, I am trying to focus on writing the first book and let it stand on its own, while having a plan for later books that all could work together as a whole once finished. It’s a fragile balance, but hopefully one I can pull off.

Thanks for reading. Follow me for more and comment down below.